Opinions, Please: Multi-Cores/Multi Units or Multi-Cores/1 Unit

Started by Aegis, April 24, 2012, 06:31:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Aegis

Question for the Team.

I have a three core processor.  Do you think it's better to have each core working on a work unit, or better to let the cores "concentrate" on one unit at a time? 

Thanks, Brian


"For you, a thousand times over." - "The Kite Runner"

Calum

3 cores working on one unit (SMP) will give you better results than 3 separate units (uniprocessor) - however, your PC must be on and folding enough to make the shorter SMP deadlines.  If your PC isn't on + folding enough of the time, 3 uniprocessor clients is your best bet as the deadlines are much longer.

Aegis

Thanks, Calum.  I tried, for a while, assigning a unit to each of the cores in my AMD processor.  I seem to be getting better results by just allowing my 3 core processor to work on one assigned unit at a time.   :)


"For you, a thousand times over." - "The Kite Runner"

Calum

If you're running the SMP client, yes, you'll definitely get better results that way as long as your PC's on enough to meet deadlines.

Aegis

Not sure if I'm running SMP.  I don't think so.  I should check - though I'm kinda tempted to just let things be.  Most days, I turn on the computer in the morning, and then turn it off before I go to sleep. 

Thanks for the continued input! :)

I wish I could have a server or Cray CX1 desktop to just dedicate to folding, but my current (modest) system is doing better than the single-core processor system I had before.


"For you, a thousand times over." - "The Kite Runner"

Calum

Quote from: Aegis on August 16, 2012, 03:03:23 PM
Not sure if I'm running SMP.  I don't think so.  I should check - though I'm kinda tempted to just let things be.  Most days, I turn on the computer in the morning, and then turn it off before I go to sleep.
Ah, I see.  If you're not running the SMP client, running 3 instances of the uniprocessor client will triple your production, as one client will only use one core.  If you're not currently running SMP, I wouldn't switch to it, as the newer units are getting shorter deadlines so your system probably wouldn't make them if it's not on 24/7.

QuoteThanks for the continued input! :)
No problem :)

QuoteI wish I could have a server or Cray CX1 desktop to just dedicate to folding, but my current (modest) system is doing better than the single-core processor system I had before.
Hah, don't we all!  Every little certainly helps though.

patio

" Anyone who goes to a psychiatrist should have his head examined. "

Calum

On the up, patio...been a while heh.
Figured I'd pop over for at least a little while, see what's happening here :)